Social Items


The question of why the island often referred to as "Taiwan" isn't consistently called "Republic of China" in international discourse is a deeply complex and politically charged issue. It's a narrative woven from historical conflicts, evolving diplomatic relations, and distinct national identities.



The Name "Taiwan": An Indigenous Origin

The name "Taiwan" itself has a fascinating origin, believed to date back to the Dutch colonial era in the 17th century. It is thought to be derived from the name of a local indigenous tribe called "Tayouan" or "Taivoan."

Loading...

Early Names: Before the Dutch arrived, the island was known by various names, including Xiaodong dao (little eastern island) and Dahui guo (the country of Dahui).

The Dutch Arrival: The Dutch East India Company established a colony in southwestern Taiwan in 1624, near present-day Tainan.

"Tayouan" as a Place: The Dutch named this settlement "Tayouan" or "Taijowan," likely based on the Taivoan indigenous people.

Adoption by Chinese: This name "Tayouan" was subsequently adopted by the Chinese, particularly the Minnan Chinese (Hokkien speakers), evolving into the familiar "Taiwan" (臺灣 or 台灣).

Official Usage: The Chinese name "Taiwan" became official during the Qing dynasty in 1684 with the establishment of Taiwan Prefecture.

Modern Usage: While the official name of the island's governing entity is the Republic of China (ROC), "Taiwan" is the name most commonly used in English and many other languages globally.

Visit my Ultimate Taiwan Travel Guide to learn more.



The "One China" Principle: An Unfinished Civil War?

The deeper political complexity stems from the Chinese Civil War. The perspective from mainland China (People's Republic of China - PRC) asserts that there is only "One China," and Taiwan is an inalienable part of it. This view posits that both the Communist Party of China (CPC) under Mao Zedong and the Kuomintang (KMT) under Chiang Kai-shek, despite their conflict, agreed on the principle of a single China, differing only on who held legitimate rule.

The current situation is often characterized by Beijing as an "unfinished civil war." In the 1950s, after the KMT retreated to Taiwan, Chiang Kai-shek sought opportunities to reclaim the mainland, including during the Korean War. However, the U.S. reportedly warned against and prohibited such actions, as a divided China was seen as serving U.S. interests.

Decades later, power dynamics shifted. As mainland China's national power surpassed Taiwan's, the prospect of reclaiming the mainland became increasingly unrealistic for Taipei. This historical trajectory, from Beijing's viewpoint, led to the rise of a "Taiwan Independence" movement, driven by internal and external factors rather than a foundational disagreement on the "One China" principle. The "One China" principle is formally recognized by the United Nations and acknowledged by many countries, including the United States (though with its own nuanced "One China policy" that differs from Beijing's principle).



Factors Behind the Call for Independence (from a particular perspective)

From this perspective, Taiwan's inclination towards independence is attributed to several factors:

  • Fears and Misconceptions of China: It suggests these fears are fueled by "Western propaganda" and a lack of understanding of modern China, proposing that young Taiwanese working in the mainland often develop new, more positive perspectives.

  • Political System Differences as an Excuse: While acknowledging the differing political systems (Taiwan's democracy vs. mainland China's communism) as a major "mismatch," this view questions if it's the actual reason for refusing peaceful reunification. It highlights China's stated offer that if Taiwan accepts "One China," "everything else is negotiable," implying that maintaining self-administration and current democratic freedoms is viable under this framework.

  • Anti-China Sentiment from Education: This perspective claims that the Taiwanese education system and media foster an "anti-China emotion," leading many Taiwanese to perceive China as an enemy without clear, well-reasoned justifications.

  • Perception of Superior Status: It suggests that a segment of the Taiwanese population views themselves as a "higher class, well-educated Chinese" compared to mainlanders, leading them to resist reunification, which they perceive as a "downgrading their status and superiority."

The provided analysis concludes that any official declaration of "Taiwan Independence" by changing its national naming would breach the "One China bottomline" and likely result in military action from mainland China. This is why, from this viewpoint, the current Taiwanese government would never officially announce such a statement.

Visit my list of Frequently Asked Questions in Taiwan (FAQs) to learn more.



Key Historical Milestones in the Separation


1949: Chiang Kai-shek's Nationalists (Republic of China) lose the civil war to Mao Zedong's Communist forces (People's Republic of China) and establish a government-in-exile on Taiwan.

1958: China bombards offshore islands held by Nationalist troops, almost sparking a war with the U.S.

1971: Taiwan (Republic of China) loses its U.N. seat, held since 1946, to the People’s Republic of China. Its diplomatic allies subsequently dwindle.

1987: Taiwan and China begin cautious rapprochement, allowing cross-Strait family visits.

1991: Taiwan formally renounces the use of force to retake the mainland.

1993: A landmark bilateral meeting takes place in Singapore.

Jan 1995: Chinese President Jiang Zemin calls for high-level talks to end hostility; Taiwan rejects the offer.

June 1995: Taiwan President Lee Teng-hui's private trip to the U.S. enrages Beijing.

March 1996: China test-fires missiles near Taiwan ahead of the island’s first democratic presidential elections.

1998: Taiwan envoy Koo Chen-fu meets Jiang in China, marking the highest-level contact in nearly five decades.

1999: Lee unilaterally redefines bilateral ties as “special state-to-state,” leading Beijing to freeze semi-official talks.

Jan 2001: Taiwan opens direct but limited trade and travel links with China.

March 2005: China’s parliament passes an anti-secession bill, authorizing the use of force if Taiwan declares independence.

2007: Taiwan bans the 2008 Beijing Olympics torch relay from the island after talks fail.

June 12, 2008: Beijing hosts two-day talks, seen as a step in new Taiwan President Ma Ying-jeou’s plan to invigorate ties.

This intricate historical backdrop continues to shape the ongoing debate, making the question of Taiwan's name and status a central point of international geopolitical discussion.



Why is it Called "Taiwan": The History of What We Know Now, Republic of China


The question of why the island often referred to as "Taiwan" isn't consistently called "Republic of China" in international discourse is a deeply complex and politically charged issue. It's a narrative woven from historical conflicts, evolving diplomatic relations, and distinct national identities.



The Name "Taiwan": An Indigenous Origin

The name "Taiwan" itself has a fascinating origin, believed to date back to the Dutch colonial era in the 17th century. It is thought to be derived from the name of a local indigenous tribe called "Tayouan" or "Taivoan."

Loading...

Early Names: Before the Dutch arrived, the island was known by various names, including Xiaodong dao (little eastern island) and Dahui guo (the country of Dahui).

The Dutch Arrival: The Dutch East India Company established a colony in southwestern Taiwan in 1624, near present-day Tainan.

"Tayouan" as a Place: The Dutch named this settlement "Tayouan" or "Taijowan," likely based on the Taivoan indigenous people.

Adoption by Chinese: This name "Tayouan" was subsequently adopted by the Chinese, particularly the Minnan Chinese (Hokkien speakers), evolving into the familiar "Taiwan" (臺灣 or 台灣).

Official Usage: The Chinese name "Taiwan" became official during the Qing dynasty in 1684 with the establishment of Taiwan Prefecture.

Modern Usage: While the official name of the island's governing entity is the Republic of China (ROC), "Taiwan" is the name most commonly used in English and many other languages globally.

Visit my Ultimate Taiwan Travel Guide to learn more.



The "One China" Principle: An Unfinished Civil War?

The deeper political complexity stems from the Chinese Civil War. The perspective from mainland China (People's Republic of China - PRC) asserts that there is only "One China," and Taiwan is an inalienable part of it. This view posits that both the Communist Party of China (CPC) under Mao Zedong and the Kuomintang (KMT) under Chiang Kai-shek, despite their conflict, agreed on the principle of a single China, differing only on who held legitimate rule.

The current situation is often characterized by Beijing as an "unfinished civil war." In the 1950s, after the KMT retreated to Taiwan, Chiang Kai-shek sought opportunities to reclaim the mainland, including during the Korean War. However, the U.S. reportedly warned against and prohibited such actions, as a divided China was seen as serving U.S. interests.

Decades later, power dynamics shifted. As mainland China's national power surpassed Taiwan's, the prospect of reclaiming the mainland became increasingly unrealistic for Taipei. This historical trajectory, from Beijing's viewpoint, led to the rise of a "Taiwan Independence" movement, driven by internal and external factors rather than a foundational disagreement on the "One China" principle. The "One China" principle is formally recognized by the United Nations and acknowledged by many countries, including the United States (though with its own nuanced "One China policy" that differs from Beijing's principle).



Factors Behind the Call for Independence (from a particular perspective)

From this perspective, Taiwan's inclination towards independence is attributed to several factors:

  • Fears and Misconceptions of China: It suggests these fears are fueled by "Western propaganda" and a lack of understanding of modern China, proposing that young Taiwanese working in the mainland often develop new, more positive perspectives.

  • Political System Differences as an Excuse: While acknowledging the differing political systems (Taiwan's democracy vs. mainland China's communism) as a major "mismatch," this view questions if it's the actual reason for refusing peaceful reunification. It highlights China's stated offer that if Taiwan accepts "One China," "everything else is negotiable," implying that maintaining self-administration and current democratic freedoms is viable under this framework.

  • Anti-China Sentiment from Education: This perspective claims that the Taiwanese education system and media foster an "anti-China emotion," leading many Taiwanese to perceive China as an enemy without clear, well-reasoned justifications.

  • Perception of Superior Status: It suggests that a segment of the Taiwanese population views themselves as a "higher class, well-educated Chinese" compared to mainlanders, leading them to resist reunification, which they perceive as a "downgrading their status and superiority."

The provided analysis concludes that any official declaration of "Taiwan Independence" by changing its national naming would breach the "One China bottomline" and likely result in military action from mainland China. This is why, from this viewpoint, the current Taiwanese government would never officially announce such a statement.

Visit my list of Frequently Asked Questions in Taiwan (FAQs) to learn more.



Key Historical Milestones in the Separation


1949: Chiang Kai-shek's Nationalists (Republic of China) lose the civil war to Mao Zedong's Communist forces (People's Republic of China) and establish a government-in-exile on Taiwan.

1958: China bombards offshore islands held by Nationalist troops, almost sparking a war with the U.S.

1971: Taiwan (Republic of China) loses its U.N. seat, held since 1946, to the People’s Republic of China. Its diplomatic allies subsequently dwindle.

1987: Taiwan and China begin cautious rapprochement, allowing cross-Strait family visits.

1991: Taiwan formally renounces the use of force to retake the mainland.

1993: A landmark bilateral meeting takes place in Singapore.

Jan 1995: Chinese President Jiang Zemin calls for high-level talks to end hostility; Taiwan rejects the offer.

June 1995: Taiwan President Lee Teng-hui's private trip to the U.S. enrages Beijing.

March 1996: China test-fires missiles near Taiwan ahead of the island’s first democratic presidential elections.

1998: Taiwan envoy Koo Chen-fu meets Jiang in China, marking the highest-level contact in nearly five decades.

1999: Lee unilaterally redefines bilateral ties as “special state-to-state,” leading Beijing to freeze semi-official talks.

Jan 2001: Taiwan opens direct but limited trade and travel links with China.

March 2005: China’s parliament passes an anti-secession bill, authorizing the use of force if Taiwan declares independence.

2007: Taiwan bans the 2008 Beijing Olympics torch relay from the island after talks fail.

June 12, 2008: Beijing hosts two-day talks, seen as a step in new Taiwan President Ma Ying-jeou’s plan to invigorate ties.

This intricate historical backdrop continues to shape the ongoing debate, making the question of Taiwan's name and status a central point of international geopolitical discussion.



Asia China Geopolitics History Name Taiwan

No comments

Let us know your thoughts!

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)